Step-by-Step Instructions
First, we prep our veggies. Take your time chopping the cabbage into those small, uniform pieces—this is the most labor-intensive part, but it’s crucial for authenticity. I like to slice the cabbage quarter thinly, then rock my knife through the pile. For the carrot, I grate it on the large holes, then give the pile a few extra chops with my knife to break down any long strands. The onion gets minced until it’s almost a paste. Combine all these in your large mixing bowl. The vibrant white and orange look so pretty together, and you can already imagine the crunch.
Now, for the magical dressing. In your medium bowl, whisk together the sugar, salt, pepper, mayonnaise, milk, buttermilk, vinegar, and lemon juice. I whisk it for a good minute until the sugar is completely dissolved and the mixture is silky smooth. This is where I made a mistake the first time: I didn’t whisk long enough and had a slightly grainy texture from undissolved sugar. Taste it! It should be boldly sweet, tangy, and salty on its own—it will mellow once it coats the cabbage. Pour this creamy elixir over your veggie mixture.
Here’s the fun part: mixing and the waiting game. Use a large spatula or spoon to fold the dressing into the cabbage until every single piece is glistening and coated. It will look a little soupy at first—don’t panic. This is normal. Cover the bowl tightly and refrigerate it for at least 4 hours, but honestly, overnight is best. I peeked every hour during my first test, but the real transformation happens when you let it be. The cabbage wilts slightly, the flavors marry beautifully, and that excess liquid gets reabsorbed, creating that perfect, creamy consistency we’re after.
Pro Tips for Best Results
Chill time is not a suggestion; it’s the law for this recipe. I tested eating it after one hour versus overnight, and the difference is night and day. The overnight slaw is mellower, creamier, and the flavors are completely unified. If you can plan ahead, do it. You’ll be rewarded with that true, familiar taste. Also, after chilling, give it one final stir before serving to redistribute any dressing that may have settled at the bottom of the bowl.
Your cutting technique matters more than you think. I’ve tried using a mandoline for ultra-thin slices and a food processor with an S-blade for a chop, but neither gave me the right texture. The hand-chopped method, while a bit more work, creates the ideal small, bite-sized pieces that hold the dressing perfectly. It’s the closest you’ll get to that classic texture without a commercial slaw cutter. Embrace the therapeutic chop!
Let’s talk about dressing consistency. If, after its long chill, your slaw seems a bit too wet for your liking, don’t add more mayo. Instead, simply drain off a little of the excess liquid from the bottom of the bowl. Conversely, if it seems too dry (which is rare), a single tablespoon of extra milk or buttermilk stirred in will loosen it right up. The cabbage continues to release water, so I always check it one last time right before I bring it to the table.
(See the next page below to continue…)